Late-autumn lawn and mature trees beside a modest original brick Tudor cottage in a private Bonnie Brae garden.

What You're Really Paying For in a Bonnie Brae Original

South Columbine Street runs a short stretch through Bonnie Brae, and in 2025 and early 2026 the city issued demolition permits for three homes on it. The first was 711 S Columbine St on February 28, 2025. Britman Construction pulled one for 900 S Columbine St on October 21, 2025. The third went to 860 S Columbine St in early January 2026. A new house has already gone up at 711, and the new-building permit for 860 went to Caliber Construction.

If you're touring Bonnie Brae this winter, those addresses tell you how the neighborhood's prices work. Two originals that were later torn down sold for roughly $900,000 to $1 million in 2023. Most 2026 sales in the assessor's Grade B class, the lower of the neighborhood's two main grades, went for $1 million to $1.75 million. When you look at a steep-roofed Tudor or a blonde-brick postwar ranch here, most of the price is the ground under it.

The rebuild wave is still running

None of this is new. The Bonnie Brae Neighborhood Association's history page says an effort to win landmark status for the neighborhood failed in the late 1980s. Since then, as people wanted more space, Bonnie Brae has seen additions and pop-tops, along with "original Bonnie Brae houses being scraped and replaced often with much larger homes." In June 2022, The Denver Post counted 17 active scrape-offs in the neighborhood.

The pace hasn't slowed much. Denver's demolition permit records list Bonnie Brae under the larger Belcaro statistical neighborhood. Between February 2025 and September 2026, they show 12 demolition permits inside Bonnie Brae's streets: on South Columbine, South Cook, South Clayton Way, South Milwaukee, South Elizabeth, East Ohio Way, and two on Bonnie Brae Boulevard itself. The two most recent were 939 S Clayton Way on August 5, 2026, and 765 S Elizabeth St on September 2, 2026. Mendoza Demolition Services held most of the 12.

The new-construction permits name the builders. In 2026, Caliber Construction received the permit for 860 S Columbine St with a declared valuation of $1,651,668, and Larraz Building Excellence got 865 S Milwaukee St at $1,075,000. Denver Design Build, Westport Development, TK Morrison Construction and Wells Construction also hold 2025 or 2026 permits in the neighborhood. Caliber's own portfolio lists several past Bonnie Brae projects.

What two demolished originals sold for in 2023

The city's sales records let you follow a lot from sale to finished house.

On September 27, 2023, 711 S Columbine St sold for $975,000 to an entity called 711 S Columbine Street LLC. The demolition permit came in February 2025, and a new-building permit followed in April with a declared valuation of $608,000. The assessor now lists a 3,416-square-foot house built in 2025 on a 6,160-square-foot lot.

Elsewhere in the neighborhood, 970 S Clayton Way sold for $891,500 on June 1, 2023. It got its demolition permit in May 2025, and Denver Design Build pulled the new-building permit that October. The assessor now records a 3,076-square-foot home built in 2025 on a 5,487-square-foot lot.

So in 2023, two standard Bonnie Brae lots of about 5,500 to 6,200 square feet, each with an original house on it, sold for between $891,500 and $975,000. Both houses were gone within two years.

Two price bands in one neighborhood

Denver's assessor gives each house a quality grade, and Bonnie Brae's recorded sales from January through September 2026 fall mostly into two bands by that grade. The table leaves out transfers recorded at $0, $1 or $10, since those are not arm's-length sales.

Assessor grade Lowest recorded sale Middle of the band Highest recorded sale
SFR Grade B $637,000 in September about $1.3 million $1,750,000 in February
SFR Grade A $1,162,500 in March $2,975,000 $5,588,321 in April

The bands touch at the edges. Two Grade A sales, $1,162,500 in March and $1,700,000 in April, landed inside the Grade B range. Every other Grade A sale was $1,961,750 or more. A few Grade B sales came in under $1 million, including $930,000 in May and $637,000 in September. Most Grade B sales landed between $1 million and $1.75 million. A single neighborhood median would fall between the two groups and describe neither.

Now set the 2023 sales beside the middle of the Grade B band. A Grade B home at about $1.3 million in 2026 sold for roughly $325,000 to $400,000 more than the two originals that changed hands in 2023 and were then torn down. The land under a typical original makes up most of what it sells for.

What demolition demand means for an original's owner

Here's the practical upshot for a buyer who wants an original Bonnie Brae home to live in. As long as companies like Caliber, Larraz and Denver Design Build keep pulling permits on these streets, an original on a full-size lot has more than one kind of potential buyer when it's time to sell, including someone who plans to rebuild. The 12 demolition permits issued in about 19 months show that demand is still there.

The same demand affects your competition today. If you're bidding on a modest original, you may be up against a buyer who mostly wants the lot. That kind of offer doesn't depend on the kitchen, the basement or the windows, so a dated original on a good lot won't necessarily sell at a deep discount for its condition.

How to read a listing lot-first

Start with the lot's square footage, which the assessor publishes for every parcel. The two lots that went from sale to new build in 2025 were 6,160 and 5,487 square feet. A larger parcel, like the 13,300 square feet the assessor lists at 720 S Milwaukee St, is in a different category.

Then look at the block. South Columbine and South Clayton Way have each had more than one demolition permit since early 2025. An original on a street like that may end up close to new construction, which can change the light, privacy and sense of scale from its yard.

Last, compare the asking price with the Grade B band. An original listed near $1 million is priced close to what the two 2023 teardown sales brought. One listed near $1.6 million is asking a buyer to pay real money for the house itself: its condition, its updates and its original character. Our earlier piece on pricing mid-century homes in Bonnie Brae covers what sellers do to earn that premium.

If a larger finished house is the goal

The Grade A band holds Bonnie Brae's highest prices. From January through September 2026, Grade A sales reached $4,715,000 in September and $5,588,321 in April, and the middle Grade A sale was $2,975,000. The middle of the two bands sits about $1.7 million apart, and that gap is what this market charged in 2026 for a higher-grade house over an original-grade one. At 711 S Columbine, getting from an original to a new house took from a 2023 sale to a 2025 build date.

Buyers at these prices move quickly metro-wide. The Denver Metro Association of Realtors' October 2026 report put the median days in MLS at 19 for detached homes listed at $1 million or more in September 2026, compared with 32 days for the whole metro market. That's a metro figure, not a Bonnie Brae one, but most of the neighborhood's 2026 sales fall in that bracket.

Our Bonnie Brae neighborhood page and buyer's guide are good places to start a shortlist.

If you've found a Bonnie Brae original you like and can't tell whether the asking price is for the house or the lot, send it to Moxie Property Group. We'll pull that block's demolition and sale history and tell you which band the listing really belongs in. Start Your Colorado Search.

Work With Us

Take the first step towards finding your dream home and contact us today. Experience the Moxie difference as we guide you through this exciting journey with unwavering dedication and expertise. Together, we'll make your Colorado home ownership dreams a reality!

Follow Us on Instagram